Comparison · 8 min read
Best Free FX Replay Alternatives for ICT Traders
FX Replay is popular for a reason — but at $30–$45/month, and with forex-only data, it's not always the right tool for an ICT trader learning Nasdaq futures. Here are the best free and futures-focused alternatives, ranked by how well they handle NQ, killzones, and Silver Bullet reps.
Quick comparison
| Tool | Price | Best for | ICT overlays | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| NQ Replay | Free | NQ / MNQ futures | Automatic (FVG, OB, Killzones, SMT) | Browser-based, 10+ years of 1s data, works on iPad. |
| FX Replay | $30–45/mo | Forex majors | Manual | Great UX, but forex-only. |
| TradingView Bar Replay | Free / Paid | All markets | Manual | Limited intraday history on free tier. |
| NinjaTrader Market Replay | Free (desktop) | Futures | Manual | Windows-only, tick data downloads. |
| ThinkOrSwim OnDemand | Free (US brokerage) | Equities / options | Manual | Requires TD/Schwab account. |
1. NQ Replay — free, futures-native, ICT-first
If you're specifically drilling ICT on Nasdaq futures, this is the closest thing to FX Replay for futures — except it's free and the killzones, fair value gaps and order blocks are drawn for you. You get 10+ years of 1-second NQ data, a $50K funded-style challenge to rehearse rules, and it runs in the browser on desktop, tablet or iPad.
- — Automatic Killzone shading (Asia / London / NY AM / NY PM)
- — One-click Silver Bullet, Unicorn and Judas Swing rehearsal
- — Multi-TP ladder, working orders, drag-to-move SL/TP on touch
2. TradingView Bar Replay
Best all-round replay if you trade multiple markets. The free tier limits intraday history and some drawing tools, so ICT traders usually outgrow it fast. Everything ICT is manual — you draw FVGs and OBs yourself.
3. NinjaTrader Market Replay
Solid for tick-accurate futures reps, but Windows-only and heavier setup — you download replay data per day. If you're not already inside the NinjaTrader ecosystem, the friction is real.
4. ThinkOrSwim OnDemand
Great if you already have a Schwab/TD account and mostly trade equities and options. Not the tool of choice for futures ICT.
Which should you pick?
If you're an ICT trader focused on NQ or MNQ, start with NQ Replay — it's free, browser-based, and every ICT concept is overlaid automatically. Keep TradingView for cross-market work, and consider FX Replay only if you specifically trade forex majors and need currency-pair depth.
Try NQ Replay free
No download, no credit card. Load a historical NQ session, step through the killzones bar by bar, and see ICT overlays drawn for you.
Open the replay